Search references for CREATIVE DISRUPTION. Phrases containing CREATIVE DISRUPTION
See searches and references containing CREATIVE DISRUPTION!CREATIVE DISRUPTION
Creative disruption (disruption concept in a creative context) was introduced in 1992 by TBWA's chairman Jean-Marie Dru. It refers to a radical change
Creative_disruption
Topics referred to by the same term
up disruption or disruptive in Wiktionary, the free dictionary. Disruption, disruptive, or disrupted may refer to: Creative disruption, disruption concept
Disruption
Technological change
"new-market disruption", which targets customers who have needs that were previously unserved by existing incumbents. "Low-end disruption" occurs when
Disruptive_innovation
American businesswoman convicted of fraud (born 1984)
the original on 2016-06-04. Retrieved 2016-10-17. Topol, Eric. "Creative Disruption? She's 29 and Set to Reboot Lab Medicine". Medscape. Archived from
Elizabeth_Holmes
British writer and poet (1916–1990)
boring qualities like obedience and deference. In Dahl's world, creative disruption is presented in such an appealing, delicious light, that you can't
Roald_Dahl
Educational year
Retrieved 2018-04-09. "Five-year high schools increasingly common, 'a creative disruption,' and soon to show improved graduation rates". OregonLive.com. Retrieved
Thirteenth_grade
Concept in economics
In economics, creative destruction (German: schöpferische Zerstörung) is a process in which new innovations replace and make older innovations obsolete
Creative_destruction
Toronto Press: 223–238. doi:10.3138/chr.2018-0082-2. S2CID 182502690. "Creative Disruption Cannupa Hanska Luger builds sculptures and installations that shatter
Settler_colonialism_in_Canada
New York-based artist, educator, and activist
topic in 2004 with The Interventionists: A Users' Manual for the Creative Disruption of Everyday Life, co-edited with Nato Thompson. In Collectivism after
Gregory_Sholette
Marketing a person's career and professional traits
focusing on visibility, consistency, and perceived authenticity. Creative disruption Dandy Dog and pony show Identity performance Influence-for-hire Impression
Personal_branding
American fashion designer
Nicholas Mirzoeff (2004). The interventionists: users' manual for the creative disruption of everyday life. MASS MoCA. ISBN 9780262201506. "The Speculative
J._Morgan_Puett
Political ideology and economic theory
Anarchist communism Consequentialist libertarianism Counter-economics Creative disruption Crypto-anarchism Definition of anarchism and libertarianism Market
Anarcho-capitalism
Israeli-American non-profit educational program
The Bronfman Fellowship is a non-profit educational program for young Jews in Israel and North America. The Bronfman Fellowship selects 26 outstanding
The_Bronfman_Fellowship
American political activist (1993–2025)
2017). "30 Under 30 Class Of 2018: The Young Stars, Visionaries And Creative Disruptors". Forbes. Retrieved April 5, 2021. Bogaisky, Jeremy; Denhart, Christopher;
Charlie_Kirk
Play by Terrence McNally
place at the Arcola Theatre in London UK, March 2018 as part of the Creative Disruption Festival. A film about the staging of the play and its reception
Corpus_Christi_(play)
1997 book by Clayton M. Christensen
century. Other examples include the disruption of the mainframe computer market by personal computers, and the disruption of the laser printer market by inkjet
The_Innovator's_Dilemma
Reserve in Canada
2024-03-13. Mason, Gregory C. (2023-03-01). "First Nations are using 'creative disruption' to foster economic growth in their communities". The Conversation
Naawi-Oodena
Native American artist in New Mexico (born 1979)
from the original on 27 December 2018. Retrieved 27 December 2018. "Creative Disruption Cannupa Hanska Luger builds sculptures and installations that shatter
Cannupa_Hanska_Luger
Any ideology based on the premise that advances in technology could bring a utopia
downside of a technology after it is invented." Accelerationism Creative disruption Crypto-anarchism Eschatology Extropianism High modernism Historicism
Technological_utopianism
American playwright (born 1968)
with Beginnings". The College Voice. Retrieved September 23, 2018. "Creative Disruption". Connecticut College Magazine. 2018. Retrieved September 23, 2018
Stefanie_Zadravec
American singer and songwriter (born 1992)
industry. The list, according to Forbes, is an "annual encyclopedia of creative disruption featuring 600 stars from 20 different industries." Skylar Grey, one
Emily_Warren
Artwork created through actions of an artist or other participants
Nato Thompson (ed.), The Interventionists: Users' Manual for the Creative Disruption of Everyday Life (MIT Press, 2006), pp. 106ff, 117ff. See also the
Performance_art
11th Deputy Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh since 2024
Archived from the original on 23 May 2022. Retrieved 31 May 2024. "Despite disruption, Cameraman Ganga Tho Rambabu earns Rs 52 crore". NDTV.com. 22 February
Pawan_Kalyan
American international advertising agency
several books by Jean-Marie Dru, such as "Disruption", "How Disruption Brought Order", and "Beyond Disruption: Changing the Rules in the Marketplace."
TBWA_Worldwide
Government system where political power lies with the people
of cosmopolitan democracy. Creative democracy is advocated by American philosopher John Dewey. The main idea about creative democracy is that democracy
Democracy
2019 American television series
Improv Comedy". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved April 26, 2019. "Creative Disruption: Just Roll with It Premieres Friday, June 14, on Disney Channel"
Just_Roll_with_It
Art practice
Gregory Sholette, eds. The Interventionists: Users' Manual for the Creative Disruption of Everyday Life. Cambridge: The MIT Press, 2004. Thompson, Nato
Social_practice_(art)
Freestyle Love Supreme November 4 Kelly Ripa & Ryan Seacrest Salma Hayek, Creative Alternatives for Holiday Shopping Shortages November 5 Kelly Ripa & Ryan
List of Live with Kelly and Ryan episodes
List_of_Live_with_Kelly_and_Ryan_episodes
British-American journalist, author and filmmaker
& Here's How It Works: Why Your World, Work, and Brain Are Being Creatively Disrupted. Random House, New York, 2012. ISBN 978-0-307-59111-1. American Kingpin:
Nick_Bilton
1957 novel by Eric Frank Russell
including slang (such as "yar" for yes and "nar" for no), Mowry's creative disruption is seen as astute. As Rupert Neethling of infinity plus states, "One
Wasp_(novel)
American artist group
Noordeman, Arjen (2004). The interventionists: users' manual for the creative disruption of everyday life. MASS MoCA. ISBN 0-262-20150-X. "Center for Tactical
Center_for_Tactical_Magic
Yuzhny Rabochy (Russian: Южный рабочий, IPA: [ˈjuʐnɨj rɐˈbot͡ɕɪj], "Southern Worker") was a Social-Democratic group formed in the South of Russia in the
Yuzhny_Rabochy
Political action that relies on the use of non-violent methods by civil groups
Boycott Civil disobedience Civilian-based defense Colour revolution Creative disruption Demonstration Dissolution of the Soviet Union Nonviolence Nonviolent
Civil_resistance
1995 fashion collection by Alexander McQueen
heavily referenced The Birds for Autumn/Winter 2024, his debut collection as creative director for the Alexander McQueen brand. British fashion designer Alexander
The_Birds_(collection)
Interdisciplinary field
revolutionised with technology", or view the field of creative technology as helping to "disrupt" the way people today interact with computers, and usher
Creative_technology
Criterion set forth by the United States Supreme Court
The substantial disruption test is a criterion set forth by the United States Supreme Court, in the leading case of Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community
Substantial_disruption
Legal theory of property rights
Politics portal Anarcho-capitalism Capitalism Classical liberalism Creative disruption Entitlement theory Individualism Outline of libertarianism Private
Propertarianism
American film executive
after due to the studio’s financial struggles. She subsequently founded Disruption Entertainment, signing a first-look deal with Paramount Pictures and producing
Mary_Parent
Subcompact hatchback
2019. Retrieved 16 July 2020. "Fiat Chrysler Is a Textbook Victim of Disruption". Motley Fool. 18 April 2016. Retrieved 16 July 2020. "Chevrolet to Produce
Chevrolet_Spark
Hitchcock Film". AnOther Magazine. Fitzgerald, Colin (9 July 2020). "CREATIVE DISRUPTION IN CÉLINE SCIAMMA'S 'PORTRAIT OF A LADY ON FIRE'". Pop Matters. Inoa
List of artists who created paintings and drawings for use in films
List_of_artists_who_created_paintings_and_drawings_for_use_in_films
Free online crowdsourced encyclopedia
the troll. If you [...] demand that something be done about constant disruption by trollish behavior, the other listmembers will cry "censorship", attack
Wikipedia
Hypotheses about Triton's origin
would have been "gentle and brief", as Triton is not subject to violent disruption or potentially dangerous post-capture orbital decay. Additionally, the
Capture_of_Triton
Video-sharing platform
into the main YouTube app. Like TikTok, it gives users access to built-in creative tools, including the possibility of adding licensed music to their videos
YouTube
British public service broadcaster
Retrieved 4 November 2022. "Creative Future". BBC. 25 April 2006. Retrieved 17 July 2025. Dowell, Ben (25 April 2006). "BBC Creative Future: the key points"
BBC
Creative advertising agency
acquisition and positioning itself as a creative "safe haven" amid industry-wise consolidation and AI-driven disruption. Mother moved to its current offices
Mother_(advertising_agency)
Canadian economist
co-founded NEXT Canada, previously The Next 36 in 2010. He founded the Creative Destruction Lab in 2012 at the University of Toronto. Agrawal is co-founder
Ajay_Agrawal
American philosopher, writer, and environmental activist
writer, and environmental activist from Oregon State University. Her early creative nonfiction writing focused on the cultural and spiritual values of the
Kathleen_Dean_Moore
Faye drink alcohol in a nearby cabana. Meanwhile, Todd and Julie have creative disagreements regarding the introduction video. Todd wants an elaborate
List of Chrisley Knows Best episodes
List_of_Chrisley_Knows_Best_episodes
volunteered Martin to be a guest speaker for Mrs. Donovan's (Sara Seegar) creative writing class. Martin says he can't get away from the office on Monday
List of The Patty Duke Show episodes
List_of_The_Patty_Duke_Show_episodes
Ukrainian composer and musician (1955–2000)
Shevchenko Avenue in Lviv. The attack occurred because his songs were deemed disruptive by a group of patrons, including Dmytro Voronov and Yurii Kalinin, who
Ihor_Bilozir
Retrieved April 14, 2025. Thomas Dunckley (August 5, 2019). ""I Have a Disruptive Attitude" – An Interview with Francis Kurkdjian". The Candy Perfume Boy
List_of_LGBTQ_Armenians
South African advertising agency
"Meet The Creative Counsel". The Citizen Newspaper. 3 September 2015. Retrieved 4 February 2021 – via pressreader. "Inspirational disruption from 2015's
The_Creative_Counsel
Lorene Scafaria (for "Too Much Birthday") Nominated Cathy Yan (for "The Disruption") Nominated Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series Brian Cox (for "All
List of awards and nominations received by Succession
List_of_awards_and_nominations_received_by_Succession
2026 concert tour by FKA Twigs
Malou Linders, James Vu Anh Pham Choreographer Assistant: Zaccary Milne Creative consultant: Leslie Travers Associate director to Theo Adams: Jordan Hunt
Body_High_Tour
Period of Afghan history from 1978 to 1992
manipulate Pashtun tribal politics. Such efforts included trying to split or disrupt tribes who affiliated with the resistance, or by compromising notables
History of Afghanistan (1978–1992)
History_of_Afghanistan_(1978–1992)
Period in Argentine cinema history
hand, writer Mario Berardi suggests that it was actually a moment of "creative freedom", in which filmmakers "made use of the impunity of the 'no one
Golden Age of Argentine cinema
Golden_Age_of_Argentine_cinema
American medical television drama series
that's not realistic. You can imagine how that would be an incredible disruption to patient care." He thought that tension over systemic issues such as
The_Pitt
"Singing Sweethearts" or he's ruined. At the performance, the girls use some creative moves to hide Betty Jo's condition, but things don't go as planned. Betty
List of Petticoat Junction episodes
List_of_Petticoat_Junction_episodes
23 December, with BBC2 resuming at 1pm the same afternoon. Threat of disruption to the BBC's festive television schedules is averted. BBC Radio networks
Timeline_of_BBC_One
AI-generated virtual influencer
26-year-old Scorpio from Barcelona, Spain. She was created by The Clueless, a creative agency founded by designer Rubén Cruz. López is portrayed as a bold and
Aitana_López
Renaissance art in Florence
an intense, daily confrontation with the artists in his circle, seen as creative authorities on beauty. The result is a sophisticated and scholarly precious
Florentine_Renaissance_art
Retrieved July 5, 2018. "Jennifer Lopez and nuvoTV Announce Exclusive Creative, Production and Marketing Partnership". Los Angeles. PR Newswire. September
Cultural impact of Jennifer Lopez
Cultural_impact_of_Jennifer_Lopez
2026 film by David Frankel
Miranda admits that she pushed Emily out of Runway because Emily lacks creative vision. Miranda tries to take the loss with grace, but while talking to
The_Devil_Wears_Prada_2
American artist
works as a creative producer: Short Film Direction: Directed multiple short films including Happy Birthday, Mr. President (2008), a disruption of visual
Kendalle_Getty
American mockumentary sitcom (2024–present)
the trend of attacks on healthcare workers. Joyce must calm them, with creative tactics as there is no money to upgrade security. Matt tries to help Bruce
St._Denis_Medical
Walter Benjamin's unfinished work
nature is expressed through perpetual boundary-shifting — a process of "creative destruction" in Schumpeter’s terms. In this sense, the capitalist cult
Capitalism_as_Religion
List of landmark US court cases by year
Category: Individual rights: Discrimination based on race and ethnicity 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis, 600 U.S. 570 (2023) Anti-discrimination laws cannot be used
List of landmark court decisions in the United States by year
List_of_landmark_court_decisions_in_the_United_States_by_year
2025 American black comedy television miniseries
Series or Movie Made for Television Julianne Moore Nominated Primetime Creative Arts Emmy Awards September 6, 2025 Outstanding Contemporary Costumes for
Sirens_(2025_TV_series)
2020 American war film by Aaron Schneider
release was delayed indefinitely and then canceled because of widespread disruption and shutdowns from the COVID-19 pandemic. Sony sold the distribution rights
Greyhound_(film)
Historical currencies of China
BCE–1368 CE)". Heritage Science. 9 56. doi:10.1186/s40494-021-00530-3. Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4
Han_dynasty_coinage
Calendar year
outage causes Heathrow Airport in London to completely shut down, with disruption expected to last for days, affecting thousands of flights around the world
2025
Sourcing services or funds from a group
Industry." in International Perspective on Business Innovation and Disruption in the Creative Industries: Film, Video, Photography, P. Wikstrom and R. DeFillippi
Crowdsourcing
AI that generates content
concluded that the US labor market had so far not experienced a discernible disruption from generative AI. Another study reported that Danish workers who used
Generative_AI
Country in northwestern Europe
generation of men, with lasting social effects in the nation and a great disruption in the social order. Britain had suffered 2.5 million casualties and finished
United_Kingdom
which was sold in 1915 and is believed to be lost. 7 January – At the 75th Creative Arts Emmy Awards in Los Angeles, Foy Vance and Ed Sheeran win the Primetime
2024_in_British_music
Series of television show
that "[m]aking The Newsreader was one of the most satisfying and joyous creative experiences that [she had] ever had". Torv also revealed that the ending
The_Newsreader_series_1
Bantu ethnic group native to Central Africa
militias. In the following months, the conflict further intensified social disruption, including the recruitment of children by AFDL–RPA forces across Uvira
Fuliru_people
American rapper and producer (born 1977)
March 13, 2012. Respers, Lisa (September 14, 2009). "Anger over West's disruption at MTV awards". CNN. Archived from the original on October 17, 2018. Retrieved
Kanye_West
Austrian-American professor of psychiatry
years 1977–78. After becoming professor emeritus, Steiner returned to creative writing, producing short stories, novel, and poems. He had been active
Hans_Steiner
Pandemic caused by SARS-CoV-2
Supply shortages were due to disruption to factory and logistic operations; shortages were worsened by supply chain disruptions from factory and port shutdowns
COVID-19_pandemic
Season of television series
the 77th Primetime Emmy Awards and 13 nominations at the 77th Primetime Creative Arts Emmy Awards. It was nominated for Outstanding Drama Series, and received
The_White_Lotus_season_3
American animated science fiction TV series
Hopper's strict "rules". At school, the group encounters Nikki Baxter, a creative "tinker" and transfer student with a pink mohawk who quickly captures their
Stranger Things: Tales from '85
Stranger_Things:_Tales_from_'85
American businessman
for self-publishing. Neller and partner Jason Epstein won the 2011 Creative Disruptor Award for the Espresso Book Machine technology. Neller is on the board
Dane_Neller
Danish disruptive education provider
communities and organizations located in Aarhus, Denmark, and surrounded by the creative and vibrant areas of Filmbyen and Sydhavn, at the edge of the city harbor
Kaospilot
Superhero media franchise
12, 2023. D'Alessandro, Anthony; Kroll, Justin (December 8, 2022). "DC Disruption Has Town Jittery: What's Next For 'Man Of Steel' & Other Sequels After
DC_Universe_(franchise)
Terrorist attack in Sydney, Australia
counter-terrorism investigation and policing (including proactive threat disruption), geography and relative unavailability of firearms and explosives, Australia
2025_Bondi_Beach_shooting
2024 DC Studios miniseries
director, Matt Reeves, supervised the writing and was involved in hiring the creative team. Filming began in March 2023 in New York but was halted in June by
The_Penguin_(TV_series)
Upcoming Marvel Studios film
been put on hold because of the writers' strike. He was happy with the creative reasoning for why a fourth film should be made, but was apprehensive about
Spider-Man:_Brand_New_Day
Most populous city in Canada
Entertainment and Creative Cluster" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on March 28, 2016. Retrieved July 3, 2015. "Culture, The Creative City". Toronto
Toronto
have to write an essay for Parents' Day, but when the day comes, she creatively rises to the occasion. 3 3 "100 Mile Walk" William F. Claxton Ward Hawkins
List of Little House on the Prairie episodes
List_of_Little_House_on_the_Prairie_episodes
Effects of pollution on the brain
zinc-copper cycles, which regulate metal metabolism in the body, are disrupted in ASD cases. Maternal exposure to insecticides during early pregnancy
Brain_health_and_pollution
aimed "to create conditions in the country for the free exercise of the creative powers of the populations inhabiting it, and the assiduous utilization
Political positions of Vladimir Zhirinovsky
Political_positions_of_Vladimir_Zhirinovsky
History of Brazilian association football club Grêmio Foot-Ball Porto Alegrense
goalkeeper Marcelo Grohe, the attacking duo of Luan and Pedro Rocha, the creative midfielder Douglas, Fernandinho, midfielder Maicon, and defender Pedro
History_of_Grêmio_FBPA
American police procedural comedy-drama TV series
friend, Celeste, to rob Vivian's, an exclusive jewelry store, after the new creative director, Valentina, bars them from attending the store's grand reopening
Elsbeth_(TV_series)
1847 novel by Emily Brontë
force in much of England, especially in West Yorkshire. This caused a disruption in "the traditional relationship of social classes" with an expanding
Wuthering_Heights
Airport terminal in Virginia, US
Washington Is a Superb Monument to Our Time Today's Problems Multiple Virtues Creative Spirit". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Archived from the original
Dulles International Airport Main Terminal
Dulles_International_Airport_Main_Terminal
Converting waste materials into new products
materials deemed too "dirty" or "hazardous". The new policy caused drastic disruptions in the global recycling market, and reduced the prices of scrap plastic
Recycling
Computer animation/Live-action Paramount Animation Nickelodeon Movies Disruption Entertainment Paramount Pictures 105 $125,000,000 $64,493,915 The fourth
List of animated feature films released theatrically in the United States (2000–2019)
List_of_animated_feature_films_released_theatrically_in_the_United_States_(2000–2019)
Air pollution that is mostly caused by cooking with polluting fuels
regenerating varieties would be most sustainable because soil stability is not disrupted due to tilling and planting. Some people view this solution as a way to
Household_air_pollution
American film producer (born 1956)
documentary producer, president of the media production company, Lichtenstein Creative Media, Incorporated. Lichtenstein began working in 1970 at age 14 as a
Bill_Lichtenstein
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
Girl/Female
Tamil
Creative
Girl/Female
Muslim
Creative
Girl/Female
Hindu
Creative
Girl/Female
Tamil
Sarjena | ஸரà¯à®œà¯‡à®¨à®¾
Creative
Sarjena | ஸரà¯à®œà¯‡à®¨à®¾
Girl/Female
Tamil
Creative
Girl/Female
Tamil
Creative, Creation
Girl/Female
Tamil
Shrijani | à®·à¯à®°à¯€à®œà®¨à¯€
Creative
Shrijani | à®·à¯à®°à¯€à®œà®¨à¯€
Girl/Female
Indian
Built; Construction; Creative Art; All Creation
Girl/Female
Hindu
Creative, Creation
Boy/Male
Tamil
Creative, Creation
Girl/Female
Tamil
Creative
Girl/Female
Tamil
Nivitha | நீவிதா, நீவீதாÂ
Creative
Nivitha | நீவிதா, நீவீதாÂ
Girl/Female
Hindu
Creative
Boy/Male
Hindu
Creation, Creative
Girl/Female
Tamil
Creative
Girl/Female
Assamese, Bengali, Gujarati, Hindu, Indian, Kannada, Malayalam, Marathi, Oriya, Sanskrit, Sindhi, Tamil, Telugu
Construction; Arrangement; Creative Art; All Creation
Girl/Female
Indian
Creative
Girl/Female
Tamil
Nivita | நீவிதா, நீவீதாÂ
Creative
Nivita | நீவிதா, நீவீதாÂ
Boy/Male
Hindu
Creative, Creation
Boy/Male
Tamil
Creation, Creative
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
Girl/Female
Indian, Tamil
Literature
Girl/Female
Muslim/Islamic
Walls of House of Kabba
Boy/Male
Tamil
Devdarsh | தேவà¯à®¤à®°à¯à®·
Worshipper of God
Boy/Male
Hindu, Indian, Malayalam, Marathi
Victorious
Surname or Lastname
Vietnamese
Vietnamese : unexplained.Dutch (De Van) : metonymic occupational name for a winnower or a maker of winnowing fans, from Middle Dutch van(ne) ‘fan’.English : Western English variant of Fann.Czech (Vaň) : from a pet form of the personal name Václav, Old Czech Vęceslav (see Vacek).Ukrainian : from a short form of the personal name Ivan, Slavic form of John.
Boy/Male
Australian, Czech, Czechoslovakian, French
Follower of Saint Denys
Female
English
Pet form of English Margaret, MAGGIE means "pearl."
Boy/Male
Swedish English Latin
Dark.
Female
Slovene
Feminine form of Slovene Jožef, JOŽEFA means "(God) shall add (another son)."Â
Girl/Female
American, Arabic, Chinese, German, Muslim
Blind
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
CREATIVE DISRUPTION
v. t.
To create or form anew.
a.
Pertaining to a demiurge; formative; creative.
a.
Having relation or reference; referring; respecting; standing in connection; pertaining; as, arguments not relative to the subject.
a.
Creative; formative.
a.
Creative; imaginative.
p. pr. & vb. n.
of Create
a.
Having the power to create; exerting the act of creation.
n.
The act of creating or causing to exist. Specifically, the act of bringing the universe or this world into existence.
n.
A forming anew; a new creation or formation.
a.
Creating, or tending to create, division, separation, or difference.
a.
Indicating or expressing relation; refering to an antecedent; as, a relative pronoun.
n.
A human being, in pity, contempt, or endearment; as, a poor creature; a pretty creature.
v. t.
To invest with a new form, office, or character; to constitute; to appoint; to make; as, to create one a peer.
n.
The quality of being creative.
a.
Relating to, or produced by, flesh or animal food; as, creatic nausea.
a.
Alt. of Preatory
n.
A relative pronoun; a word which relates to, or represents, another word or phrase, called its antecedent; as, the relatives "who", "which", "that".
a.
Restive.
a.
Creating anew; as, re-creative power.
n.
One who, or that which, relates to, or is considered in its relation to, something else; a relative object or term; one of two object or term; one of two objects directly connected by any relation.